SPFBO XI Finalist Review: To Touch a Silent Fury by R.A. Sandpiper

Blurb:

A sprawling romantasy debut, filled with dragons, deceit and a delicious slow-burn romance.

She rides to claim her fate.

As the first and only woman in the Moontouched Brotherhood—a magical order stationed on a stormy island—Tani lives surrounded by men who see her as an ill omen at best. She desperately awaits the day when she can unlock her full powers and free herself from this restrictive life.

He flies to burn it down.

Lang, an insubordinate Crown Prince, holds the reins to one of the few dragons left in the world. When he visits the Moontouched Brotherhood, he learns of Tani’s power—and her potential. If she's able to unlock her full powers, her magic could topple empires.

Tani would be a threat to any kingdom—including Lang’s. He knows he can’t allow her to fulfill her fate, but neither can he bear the thought of giving her up to his warmongering father.

And so they find themselves at odds: Tani, determined to claim her magic. Lang, to destroy it by any means possible. But despite everything, they can’t resist the growing sparks between them, even as it might be their shared downfall.


Review:

To Touch a Silent Fury by R.A. Sandpiper

SFF Insiders is here to provide you with our official rating for the finalist book, To Touch a Silent Fury by R.A. Sandpiper! Check out what our SPFBO judging team had to say below.

Amanda

Tanidwen is the only girl in The Brotherhood. Her life has been a fight on their secluded island where she’s trained with the other Moontouched, her only friend holding secrets of his own. When it’s Tani’s turn to receive her Fate, her world starts moving in ways she was not prepared for. Why the Dragon Prince himself is at her ceremony is the least of her worries as her Fate is sealed.

I was a Tani stan from the very beginning. I love when “not like other girls” actually makes sense for a character. Her upbringing as a pariah was believable, isolating and difficult. Did she suffer from a She’s All That paradox? A bit. (For anyone who isn’t old, let me put it this way… Do I believe an island full of boys and only boys just never happened to notice how devastatingly gorgeous she was because she was “wearing glasses”, no.) That said, being in her head was always a joy, and her relatability, vulnerabilities, and sheer wit were really wonderful to be with, which we were for most of our chapters. Though it was a duel pov and we did get a good few chapters from Langnathin, it was mostly Tani driven. I was less inclined to buy into Lang’s character at first, our dragon riding prince and misunderstood baddie trying to balance all the directions he’s pulled in, but his chapters quickly grew on me. I was left wishing I had more of his perspective at times as I unwound the motivations in the story. With our surrounding characters, political influences, and machinations of the elite, we watch our main characters with very little nail left to bite by the end.

And for some of that I had to applaud the worldbuilding. In a world that honors the senses, with five kingdoms that practice honing their designated sense, dedicated to the five gods that bore the world and sent the sun and stars on their journey, there are some born on the first night of the season, at the full moon, with abilities only their Fates can truly unlock. I enjoyed the world set before us, and though strict designations of senses is a little on the less believable side, I thought the endeavor was an interesting take to explore. We had different seasons, tracked time a bit differently and had a lot of fun lore to uncover. As the story unfolded I was intrigued by the way the senses dynamics played out, personally, culturally, and politically. The Threads and their pseudo-spiritual order was a great twist on a gifted magic system. One could say that those powers bestowed on certain characters were rather convenient, but in the story, with themes of fate and autonomy, the idea that the gifts met their arc almost innately was fun for me to mull around.

I can’t say too much about the plot because spoiling this story before you jumped in wouldn’t be nearly as fun, but I was enthralled. One thing after the other kept me flipping the pages. I finished this story faster than any other in the competition, I could not get enough. Were some things predictable? Sure. But the entertainment, characters, and overall tension kept me One More Chaptering until the end. I came away knowing two things definitively. I need the next book (I’m looking at you, Rachel), and I would really love a baby dragon.

The prose here is artful and understated. I loved the way this story just flowed, not tripping over its own words while still being a part of the atmosphere. It was vibing. Sandpiper can write, and instead of proving it by slapping you in the face, she proves it by simply telling the story. It felt confidence in what it had to say. I will say, I did struggle a bit with mere formatting when telepathic conversations were happening, and I wonder if that’s something that will change with its new publication.

All in all, out of all the beautiful books I have read in this competition, I think this one accomplished what it set out to do the best. It was a fantastic story I cannot wait to continue, one that will live in my mind rent free. I understand there are so many novels in SPFBO, with so many merits to go around. But for this one reader, this was my personal favorite.


Grady

To Touch a Silent Fury is an ambitious Romantasy novel rife with style and heart, and delivered with a polished voice making for smooth reading. Unfortunately for me, it’s also at times held back by a disjointed world underpinned by unbalanced pacing.

In full transparency, I’m usually not the target audience for Romantasy books, and they’re not stories I naturally gravitate toward. So if some criticisms are better taken with a grain of salt, please, by all means do so.

As a book squarely in the Romantasy genre, author R.A. Sandpiper checks the boxes for many of its prominent tropes:

● Enemies-to-Lovers

● Fated Mates / Magical Bonds

● Grumpy & Sunshine

● Morally Gray Love Interest

● Forbidden Love & Court Intrigue

Most of these are implemented straight-forwardly, but there is a twist to the Fated Mates trope central to the story and character motivations. I won’t spoil specifics, but this drives the tension while adding layers of character depth, specifically for our female main character, Tani.

Tani has a strong clear voice that shines through the page. Because of circumstances outside her control, she’s compelled to develop her own plans, giving herself a route to both freedom and power. This level of ambition creates depth beyond her otherwise pure-of-heart nature. 

Meanwhile, Lang was a fun and convincingly morally gray Dragon Prince. His connection with his Red Dragon was entertaining, and their telepathic banter spotlighted his complex moral framework time and again.

The drama between these main characters along with ever-present magical and political intrigues, all combine to serve a compelling beating heart for the story. It helps that Sandpiper’s writing is so clear and evocative. Sentence and section-levels are consistently paced smoothly and keeps this larger book moving quickly.

Despite all the harmonic synchronicity, some aspects of the characters didn’t line up for me in ways that pulled me out of the story. 

For Tani, I found it difficult to buy-in to her cosmically magnetic beauty. In the beginning, on the island of Eavenfold, there was little indication from her or those around her, that she was especially beautiful, let alone that this would be so important to the story. Everywhere else she goes, men are throwing themselves at her feet, begging for dances, for her attention and even her hand. Instead in our initial impression we’re mostly left with reflections on her being the only woman on Eavenfold. Yet regardless of being surrounded by many young and old men, her beauty didn’t seem relevant to her treatment by them beyond a single boy’s crush. While her experience there was important to the plot, her story really seemed to begin only once she left the island.

Further, she’s a main character without any obvious internal flaws. She’s pure of heart, yet cunning. She’s powerfully magical, yet humble. Whip smart, yet disciplined. For stories with complex characters and drama between them, I look for some flaws for her to fix within herself. It’s only at the end of the book there’s a potential problem evidenced by her actions. For me it is too late to have much meaning to the story at hand, but it does set up the next book to hopefully take a closer look and see if she can grow as a person.

As for Lang, some of his decision-making didn’t seem very logical, particularly around the time of the tournament (there wasn’t ANY other option?). Of course poor decision-making can be a feature rather than a defect, but lacking any kind of acknowledgement in the story made these choices feel odd. 

Relatedly, his attitude toward Tani also seemed at odds with his own stated goals: he wants to marry not just a beautiful woman, but one who is intellectual and ambitious as well. Yet his thoughts show he values Tani’s intellect and personality only minimally compared to his utter infatuation with her unbelievable beauty. “A woman to fight wars over,” I believe he said. Maybe this disconnect was intentional, an attraction that ran deeper in the minds of both author and audience, but again, some kind of indication that this was the case could have helped the incongruency feel more natural.

Beyond the characters, how was the storytelling? Here we have dual first-person perspectives between our mains. Through them, the moment-to-moment events were straightforward and effective. The focus remained on the characters and their motivations. It’s through this lens that R.A. Sandpiper’s worldbuilding and lore weaving is done seamlessly.

While the linear plot was stitched together well for the most part, there were a couple rough patches. One, for me, is the beginning section at Eavenfold in relation to the rest of the story. The other was a prominent time-jump that had its own mixed impact for me. 

With the years long time-jump came new cultural experiences to help flesh out the world and make it three-dimensional. However while I think this was a great choice and direction, it ultimately didn’t work for me as it served more as a functional bridge that could have had more of an impact on Tani especially, but who seemed to come out of her time in the wilderness largely unchanged (beyond learning how to be quiet in her movements). 

As a minor example, when she pretended to originate from the region of the time-jump, I was craving her to use a single, “I measure,” phrase as it was a unique locally-specific idiom. But I was left disappointed when she never leaned into it as part of her ruse. It’s a small detail, but there were other missed opportunities where her deception felt shallow compared to how long she spent in that area. And in that way, her growth in that time also felt shallow.

Regardless, this period led to our characters reconnecting in intriguing fashion—which ultimately was its most important purpose. 

Throughout the story, the use of dragons worked well also. They weren’t overdone nor too daring, but they organically related to the characters while offering interesting lore and magic implications to chew on. How their eyes “swap” with their bonded humans was a particularly good example of this. In the context of a duology, the dragons are poised well for an even larger stage to shine in the final book.

As we reached the end of the story, I liked the final sections as tensions came to a head breathlessly. The decisions made, the reactions and betrayals felt by the characters, and where the different pieces all end up aligned—it all sets up book two really well for a fun conclusion.

Overall, To Touch a Silent Fury is a solid and enjoyable book. Developmentally there are certainly some sore spots for me, but thankfully while reading they’re often overshadowed by the strength of the characters and the tension in the storytelling by R.A. Sandpiper. I look forward to seeing how this story concludes.


Jon

"To Touch a Silent Fury" was definitely a change of tone compared the book I finished just before starting it. But in the end, also vaguely similar. Less weird, but still, "Acceptance"  by Jeff VanderMeer, and the setting of R.A. Sandpipers book deal with topics of, well, accepting what has happened and making due with what has been given.

Of course, one is also a fever dream that includes multiverses and madness, and "To Touch a Silent Fury" has romance, dragons and murder.

To start off, we have Tani and Lang, two very opposite people.

Tani is a part of the Moontouched Brotherhood, due to her being born with white hair and white eyes. She's determined, hates being a part of the Moontouched Brotherhood due to her being the only woman there, and wants a Fate that befits her as a Touchlander.

Then, there's Lang, the Crown Prince of the Sightlands with a streak of insubordination. As a person, he loves his bonded dragon above all, and just wants to get on with life due to his family being a pain to be with. Literally and figuratively.

After that, there's the world building. Normally, I'd do the plot first, however a brief summation of the plot would only make sense if I clarified what some of the world is doing because otherwise it'd be all over the place.

First, I alluded to Touchlanders and the Sightlands. And the Moontouched Brotherhood.

Let me clear up the Moontouched Brotherhood first because the other two are part of a five grouped thing and there's a whole thing there that is confusing but somewhat makes sense at some point. The Moontouched Brotherhood is made up of those born under the moon with white hair and white eyes. It's a male only institution, except it isn't, because there's one outlier who doesn't know why she's there, but she is so yolo, I guess.

Once they finish their education, they get picked by the the five elders, threads, for a fate, sticking with a theme of five, between death, marriage, knowledge, acquisition, and service. I won't elaborate further because we'd be here a while, but that determines where one would end up.

Now, to the Touchlanders and the Sightlands. I said earlier they are part of a group of five, which is, in essence, the five senses we have, but each group has that one sense dialed up to absurd degrees. Those who are Soundlanders hate noise, because, well, sensitive ears. Touchlanders like touching things because they gain more information than normal that way. Sightlanders see very well, Tastelanders are supertasters, very good for a poisoner or poison tester. And the Scentlanders have really good noses, to the point of madness.

Oh, besides all that, there's also dragons, dragon bonding and riders.

All of that wall of text has something to do with the plot to make it more easy to explain here.

Tani, as part of the Moontouched Brotherhood, reaches her graduation day, gets picked for the worst one, Lang is on the island at the same time, figures out what magic Tani can use, and decides, because he can, that it's better if she died or was broken in some way.

That leads to the games, that is mentioned in the blurb for the book, with Tani supposed to marry the winner, and Lang wanting there to be no winner. All the while, there's a dragon circling around Lang wanting him to be safe, and ready to burn things if necessary. Shenanigans happen, a time jump occurs, some scuffles start occurring between the Taste people and the Sound people while the Touchlands, and Scentlands are just existing, with the Sightlanders looking for the Crown Prince to marry. More shenanigans happen, and book two is hinted at with the end.

Now, if I had to critique one thing here, it'd be that the first part of the book, the whole island and marriage fate part, is wholly unnecessary. It is already mentioned in the blurb, so what would've made it more fun to read would be a world that feels slightly more lived in, with more happening beyond the characters of Tani and Lang, making parts of it feel less like blocks of things that need to happen, and more a natural part of the story, and if the beginning was cut, there'd be more room for it to do that and breathe a bit more.

Naturally, that is my own opinion, so take it with a grain of salt, and read it for yourself before agreeing or disagreeing with it.

Overall, if you enjoy a romance novel with a slowish burn, magic, dragons and a lot of lore, "To Touch a Silent Fury" by R.A. Sandpiper is for you.


Khan

Set against a world of warring kingdoms, ancient magic and dwindling dragon numbers, To Touch a Silent Fury introduces us to Tani, the only woman among the Moontouched Brotherhood, whose future is determined by a Fate Ceremony that could change the course of her life. Meanwhile, Lang, a rebellious Crown Prince with a rare dragon bond and a complicated relationship with his father’s ambitions, arrives on the island of Eavenfold on a diplomatic mission. When Tani is assigned an unexpected fate, the paths of these two characters become increasingly intertwined, setting the stage for a story filled with secrets, conflicting loyalties, magic and the ever-present question of whether trust can survive when everyone has something to hide.

One of the things I particularly appreciated about this book was its pacing. The story moves along at a satisfying rate, introducing readers to the world and its history as the narrative unfolds rather than overwhelming them with pages of exposition. The worldbuilding feels naturally integrated into the story, allowing you to gradually understand its history, customs and underlying complexities without taking away from the momentum of the plot. For a fantasy novel with an established world and an intriguing magical history, I thought this balance was handled particularly well.

The magic system was another standout element for me. The concept of individuals being Moontouched, with their abilities determined by the Threads they possess and the criteria they must fulfil to unlock their full potential, was genuinely fascinating. It adds another layer of intrigue to the world and makes the magic feel distinctive rather than following familiar fantasy conventions. The dragon-bonding aspect was equally compelling. The connection formed when a dragon hatches and bonds with an individual brings something special to the story, and I was particularly interested in how these bonds influence the wider world and its characters.

However, what really carried the story for me was its characters, particularly Lang and Tani. Both are developed exceptionally well, and their relationship is easily one of the most engaging aspects of the book. Their dynamic has plenty of ups and downs, with moments of tension, vulnerability and genuine affection. That said, I did find myself getting frustrated with them on occasion. Their tendency to conceal information and make decisions under the assumption that they are protecting one another often achieves the exact opposite. A few honest conversations could have saved them considerable trouble! Nevertheless, this is also what makes their relationship interesting, as learning to trust one another and communicate openly becomes an important part of their development.

As the first instalment in a series, this book also deserves credit for knowing when to move things forward. It doesn’t spend unnecessary time dragging out particular storylines or overexplaining elements that readers can discover along the way. Instead, it establishes its foundations, develops its characters and brings the central narrative to a satisfying point before introducing another intriguing direction for the series to explore.

Overall, To Touch a Silent Fury was an engaging fantasy read with an interesting world, a distinctive magic system and two wonderfully developed central characters. There were moments when I wanted to shake Lang and Tani into having an honest conversation, but their journey made for a compelling read. I’m certainly interested to see where R.A. Sandpiper takes this story next, and I’m looking forward to discovering what awaits these characters in the next instalment.

Kristen

War, dragons, Fate. Tani calls the island holding the Moontouched Brotherhood her home. She studies and prepares for her Fate ceremony, one which will finally provide her an escape from the island and brothers that loathe her unnatural existence. Lang, the Crown Prince, is sent by his power hungry father to perform a diplomatic visit to the Brotherhood. During his time on the island, he watches as the Brotherhood bestows a Marriage fate for Tani where she must marry the victor of an upcoming tournament. Lang soon learns that if Tani fulfills her Fate and comes into her true power, she would have the potential to manipulate a person’s emotions and thoughts, putting them completely under her control. They soon both attend the tournament, with Lang intending to break Tani’s Fate so her power does not become a weapon against his father’s kingdom. 

This book switches between two POV’s and they both balance each other quite well. Tani is the only Moontouched woman of the Brotherhood on the remote island of Eavenfold, and Lang is the arrogant and clever Dragon Prince who has bonded with a rare ruby dragon. Now I’m not one who delves too deeply into the fantasy romance genre, but Sandpiper has crafted these two characters and given them so much depth that I couldn’t help but be drawn in. The relationship grows in many ways as the plot progresses, sometimes even falling in and out of each other's orbit for periods of time. I particularly enjoyed this as it allowed them both to really build their own personalities, especially Tani after the events of the tournament where she is to meet her Fate and gain full use of her power. These two circle each other the entire book until it comes to an intense conclusion that you might see coming based on the build up, but at the same time you won't see coming and be left with a bit of shock. 

The magic system of the story is quite intriguing. From lands being divided based on the five senses, children who are born touched by the moon and cast away to a remote island for fear of their powers, powerful and rare dragons, and fates assigned to Moontouched individuals based on reading their blood, Sandpiper crafts a truly unique system that draws readers in. I do wish that we could have explored a bit deeper into the magic behind the five senses, however, we did get a taste of what the people of each land could do. This isn’t a deal breaker for me as a reader because I can see how this aspect can potentially be expanding in the next installment. 

For our dragons, one thing I appreciated was that they were shown to have great power and strength, but they weren't overused like how some other stories use them as unbeatable war machines. Additionally the concept of swapping eye color after a dragon bonds with its chosen person was unique to see. It was also enjoyable that the dragons had their own personalities and didn’t feel “cookie cutter”. 

Overall, I deeply enjoyed Sandpiper’s writing. To Touch a Silent Fury is easily one of the top five indie books I have read this year. I am anxiously awaiting the next installment and will not hesitate to drop what I’m doing to jump back into the masterfully crafted world they have created. 


SFF Insiders Rating: 8/10

 
Next
Next

The Silver Crystal by Ryan Lanz